$5.9 Million Resolution in Dram Shop Liability Case Involving Overserved Underage Driver

A $5.9 million settlement has been reached in a  dram shop liability case litigated by The Haggard Law Firm’s Maegan Bridwell and Douglas McCarron along with co-counsel Hampton Keen and Austin Diaz. The case stemmed from the death of a 32-year-old wife and mother who was killed by an intoxicated underage driver after being overserved alcohol at a. St Lucie County, FL restaurant and bar.

Per terms of the settlement the names of the parties involved are confidential.
 
A Preventable Tragedy
On February 7, 2021, a 19-year-old male patron was served 14 alcoholic beverages over several hours at a local Bar and Grill without ever being asked for identification. Severely intoxicated, the underage customer left the bar in his pickup truck, crossed the center line of a two-lane road, and collided head-on with the victim’s vehicle.
The young mother died instantly from blunt force trauma, leaving behind her high school sweetheart and husband, and their daughter who was just shy of her first birthday.
Trial lawyer Maegan Bridwell

 

 

 

 

 

 

trial lawyer, partner, Douglas McCarron

 

Legal Action and Accountability
A dram shop liability lawsuit was filed against the local restaurant and bar and the property owner where the establishment operated. The lawsuit alleged that both defendants were responsible for operating the bar and allowing a minor to be served to the point of intoxication.
The case was complicated by a dispute over whether any insurance coverage applied to the incident, but through determined litigation and strategic advocacy, Bridwell and McCarron secured a $5.9 million resolution against both defendants.
Understanding Florida’s Dram Shop Law
Under Florida’s Dram Shop Law (Fla. Stat. §768.125), bars, restaurants, and alcohol-serving establishments can be held legally responsible when they knowingly serve alcohol to minors or visibly intoxicated persons who later cause injury or death. This law exists to promote responsible alcohol service and protect the public from the devastating consequences of drunk driving.
The Importance of Accountability
This case underscores the life-and-death importance of responsible alcohol service. When establishments fail to verify IDs or overserve intoxicated patrons, they put innocent lives at risk. The Haggard Law Firm’s work in this case highlights how civil litigation can drive accountability and systemic change, ensuring that safety and responsibility are not ignored in the pursuit of profit.
Proven Results in Dram Shop and Wrongful Death Cases
For more than 30 years, The Haggard Law Firm has been a national leader in dram shop liability, wrongful death, and negligent security cases. The firm’s attorneys have successfully represented victims and families across Florida and the country, securing landmark results and fighting for justice in the face of preventable tragedy.

Contact The Haggard Law Firm

The aftermath of a fatal crash can be devastating, but you do not have to face it alone. Our experienced attorneys are ready to help your family pursue justice with compassion and determination.

Contact The Haggard Law Firm today for a free consultation. We’ll review your case, explain your rights, and fight for the accountability and closure you deserve.

$15.5 Million Settlement in Tragic Drowning of 3-Year-Old at Seminole County Apartment Complex

The Haggard Law Firm’s Adam Finkel and Michael Haggard secured a $15.5 Million settlement in a child fatal-drowning retention pond case. 
 
During the early evening hours of January 12, 2024, tragedy struck at the Huntington Reserve Apartments in Seminole County, Florida. Three-and-a-half-year-old Kai Goodlander left his family’s apartment on a dark, rainy night—perhaps headed toward the nearby pool or playground. Minutes later, Kai was discovered in a retention pond adjacent to the property’s recreational area. Despite rescue efforts, Kai drowned.
 
Seeking answers and accountability, Kai’s mother turned to The Haggard Law Firm. Through an extensive investigation, attorneys Haggard and Finkel uncovered a shocking truth: the so-called “pond” was not meant to hold water at all.
Negligence in Property Management and Maintenance
The area where Kai drowned was actually a dry detention pond—a stormwater management system designed to temporarily collect runoff and then drain completely. Like a colander, the floor of the pond should allow water to seep through, keeping the area dry and safe.
However, the investigation revealed that negligent property ownership and management  allowed this pond to deteriorate into a dangerous and water-retaining pit. The failure to properly inspect, maintain, or repair the stormwater system directly led to the conditions that caused Kai’s death.
Shockingly, property management employees admitted under oath that they had no knowledge of how to maintain a dry detention pond, never hired qualified experts, and did nothing to ensure compliance with safety or environmental standards. The property owner likewise neglected their legal duty of care to maintain the pond safely and to hire competent management professionals.
Haggard and Finkel(behind Haggard at microphones) during a recent news conference on a separate case.
Justice and Accountability
As trial approached, the mounting evidence of negligence led to two significant settlements:
  • TPI Management Services, LLC settled for $6 million
  • Huntington Reserve Associates, Ltd. settled for an additional $9.5 million
Together, these settlements totaled $15.5 million, bringing some measure of justice and accountability for Kai’s family.
A Call for Safer Stormwater Management in Florida
This case underscores the critical importance of proper stormwater system maintenance and drowning preventionacross Florida and the nation. Retention and detention ponds, while common, can pose hidden dangers if neglected.
As studies have shown, drowning prevention requires multiple layers of protection, including:
  • Regular inspection and maintenance of water management systems
  • Installation of protective barriers or fencing
  • Compliance with all safety and environmental regulations
There was no reason this tragedy should have occurred. Proper maintenance and adherence to safety standards could have saved Kai’s life.
At The Haggard Law Firm, we remain committed to holding negligent property owners accountable and fighting for families impacted by preventable drownings and unsafe premises conditions. Contact US